(compiled by Blair Mulholland)
The Worst New Zealand Songs of All Time
Well PNN seems to have beaten me to it. Unfortunately, Mr Albarn's list is hugely inadequate. He has left out some of the worst recordings ever committed to vinyl anywhere in the world. It's time to reveal the Official Worst New Zealand Songs of All Time (TM), in descending order:
1) Shane - Saint Paul
This song has to be heard to be believed. I'll bet there are people who have spent years in Carrington just aching to erase the memory of this travesty from their besieged minds. It's a ghastly hash of stolen Beatles melodies and embarrasing references to Beatles lyrics, that might have been funny was Shane not so obviously taking himself seriously. No, scratch that, Weird Al Yancovic himself could not even raise a smirk with it. The singing is crap too - it comes off like a third rate Scott Walker imitation. In fact, there is nothing remotely redeeming about Saint Paul, and in the best tradition of Pat Buchanan I'd be quite happy to believe that New Zealand's economic decline over the last thirty years is entirely God's curse for spawning a song of such untalented worthlessness.
2) Paul Holmes - Wichita Lineman (or any of his music really)
Holmes is a lousy interviewer whose fondess for the yes/no question belies his popularity. However, he is still better at interviewing than he is at singing. Of course this week his interest in Shrek the sheep has cleared up the mystery - Holmes's influences are now all too apparent.
3) Hayley Westenra - Who Painted the Moon Black?
That would have been you, Hayley, by singing such utter garbage. Now don't get me wrong, Hayley is a marvelous singer, who, to be frank, would be more at home on the cover of Ralph than the cover of the Womens Weekly, but um... the song... um... bad call, love! Lyrics rhyming "moon" with "balloon", a chorus as mind-numbingly inane as "Who painted the moon black?/Oh won't you... come back..." and a string arrangement that muzak would be proud of makes this the third worst New Zealand song of all time. The only way it could be worse would be if Paul Holmes covered it.
4) Double J and Twice the T - Def To Be Green
Well if it isn't New Zealand's own Vanilla Ice? This mock Run DMC City Council advertisement was in no way possibly "Def". In fact, hearing it will make you wish you were deaf.
5) Tim Finn and Herbs - Parihaka
Tim Finn tries to teach New Zealand about its history. Fails. Peter Garrett he is not. Actually I couldn't decide whether this or his appalling NZ Cricket anthem Runs in the Family was worse, so that can be number six. It sank even lower than the fortunes of the team in 1995, which was no mean feat really.
7) Blackjack - Kurt Cobain
Blackjack are a bunch of bogan metallers from Hamilton. In 1994 Kurt Cobain shot himself, then Blackjack released a drippy acoustic guitar driven power ballad that made everyone who heard it want to do the same thing. If I ever wave a lighter for this song, it will be to burn the damn thing.
8) Split Enz - Shark Attack
Score one for PNN and the most overrated New Zealand band of all time! Kitch and clumsy with layers of extra cheese for good measure. Geez, we're only up to number eight and Tim Finn has three songs already!
9) South Side of Bombay - What's the Time Mr Wolf?
Time a certain reggae bar band realised a childrens game should never form the basis for a song. Bob Marley would spew.
10) Ngaire - To Sir With Love
Take a classic torch song from the 60s. Add beats. Suck any life or emotion out of the song in the process.
I'm not done yet. There's plenty more where that came from, and I'm sure I've missed out songs that should be there. But that will do for the moment.


Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Facebook
Google
Technorati
Lydia by Fur Patrol. All I can think is ...
Lydia by Fur Patrol. All I can think is "why?!" whenever I hear it,and was it that song or the other equally repulsive one by then that had a dance routine in the music video of a slow pop rock ballad?How patriotic to have this topic during NZ music month. Still,you said what everyone was thinking!
//Lydia by Fur Patrol I'll second ...
//Lydia by Fur Patrol
I'll second that.
i saw fur patrol in upper hutt back in ...
i saw fur patrol in upper hutt back in 98 and boy did they suck
Umm, Fur Patrol totally rock dude. No ...
Umm, Fur Patrol totally rock dude.
No question, no doubt.
Julia is a rock goddess in my eyes & I can't wait to see them again in Hamilton.
anything by minuit really.. but ...
anything by minuit really.. but particularly menace.
the singer and her voice REALLY creep me out... literally makes my skin crawl.
And impressive reaction to get out of anyone with your music, but probably not the desired effect.
*shudder*
Yeah, I don't want to hassel Minuit ...
Yeah, I don't want to hassel Minuit too much, but after seeing them at Splore they kinda reminded me of an electronica version of an aussie pub-band!
Still, for me, there are hundreds of worse acts to mention - like Elemeno P's latest crap (the one with the orientation photos in the vid), or the latest tripe from 3 the Hard Way (from the producers that baught you OMC for fucks sack!!! so go figure!
I'd also add Dave Dobbyn, and any one ...
I'd also add Dave Dobbyn, and any one of his 3 chord anthems. It's probably not the worst music in NZ, but it definately isn't the best by a long shot. Natures Crap indeed! Infact most of that music should be relegated back to the 80's, and not celebrated to the effect that it still is. I've noticed the Silver Scrolls have opened up a bit it the last few years (not the standerd old-school pat on the back), but I really don't want to hear Loyal ever again!
//or the latest tripe from 3 the Hard ...
//or the latest tripe from 3 the Hard Way
bleugh.
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep ...
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep me out... literally makes my skin crawl.
I strongly disagree, i find Ruth Carr's voice to be very listen worthy.
yeah, that's the thing.. I can't even ...
yeah, that's the thing.. I can't even pinpoint why exactly her voice and mannerisms disturb me so... it just creates a rather visceral reaction...
Aside from that I think they're pretty shit anyway
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep ...
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep me out... literally makes my skin crawl.
*shudder*
autistk
ah, ya big girl!
totally on the money- minuit are a ...
totally on the money- minuit are a glass & a 1/2 of full cream diarrhoea
In my opinion Minuit would have to be ...
In my opinion Minuit would have to be the worst NZ band currently polluting the airwaves. Followed closely by the highly cringeworthy ElemenoP. I mean, what the hell ... ? How can people listen to this in all seriousness? I know that a band doesn't necessarily need to have bucket-loads of vocal talent to succeed, but surely just a hint of it ... surely?
Totally disagree - I love her voice. ...
Totally disagree - I love her voice. I'm not usually an electronic fan, but there's something about minuit that tickles me in a very, very nice way... each to their own.
nothing like moloko- roisin sounds cool ...
nothing like moloko- roisin sounds cool & relaxed- the minuit chicksounds like shes trying to be cool- & its making her nervous
which is why ive never visisted your ...
which is why ive never visisted your flat mel
sorry- visisetested...
sorry- visisetested
Miss O... I only said she reminded me ...
Miss O... I only said she reminded me of Moloko. And I like her slightly nervous aura... it is cute :)
I really like Minuit. The vocals ...
I really like Minuit. The vocals remind me of Moloko at times... and I like Moloko. I would say her voice is very interesting. And so are the breaks that she sings over....
I must say, however, that the crowd that turned up to their Studio9 performance last month took me aback. '91zm' people.
that's studio for ya...
that's studio for ya
I don't mind them, she's kinda wierd ...
I don't mind them, she's kinda wierd but that makes her cool
someone mentioned Dave Dobbyn? I dont ...
someone mentioned Dave Dobbyn? I dont mind a fair chunk of his stuff, but 'loyal' has me blowing chunks (wicked pun i know, it took me ages).
I was a pre americas cup hater of the song as well, so the 3 months they played that constantly on tv were unbearable. the royalties for that must have been incredible.
nesian mystik get on my tits as well. good on them for doing so well but talk about overexposure. for a while there I thought they must have crawled halfway up my ass. every time i turned around they were there.
Lame humor represent.
the song loyal is great but i just ...
the song loyal is great but i just can't help thinkin bout that guy who betrayed nz by supporting the one boat that won errrrr wateva happened to LOYALTY
People do it all the time.... think ...
People do it all the time.... think rugby, netball etc
Loyal is quite a tolerable song, I wouldn't put it on a mix tape or anything, but it's well written
I think Ruth's voice is great
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep ...
//the singer and her voice REALLY creep me out... literally makes my skin crawl.
Minuit is GREAT. I love their cd and it's played often in my flat.
[ http://melsphotos.tripod.com ]
yeh i know....but its still bad thats ...
yeh i know....but its still bad thats wat i think personally
Rubicon - Bruce no contest...
Rubicon - Bruce
no contest
While I do find that song highly ...
While I do find that song highly repulsive,at least they weren't trying to be serious in writing such a low grade song. Being disgusting is the highest form of humour,I'm sure someone somewhere must have said that once...
Any song by Rubicon should be up there ...
Any song by Rubicon should be up there in the top Worst NZ songs.
I can't believe Blair left that one ...
I can't believe Blair left that one out. It is the cream of the crap.
Why do songs like that get attention?...
Why do songs like that get attention?
yep! They are shit!!!!...
yep! They are shit!!!!
// Any song by Rubicon should be up ...
// Any song by Rubicon should be up there in the top Worst NZ songs.
yup
Amazing! This is the first forum where ...
Amazing! This is the first forum where I have seen everyone agreeing!!!
It must be true then, Rubicon=shit! That certainly has my vote too!
same i agree that RUBICON IS SHIT....
same i agree that RUBICON IS SHIT.
that animated video they did parodying ...
that animated video they did parodying LOTR, terminator and the Matrix was a shocker. possibly the most awful video made in the last few years. that died a death.
hahaha yup rubicon is shit . They shame ...
hahaha yup rubicon is shit . They shame the nation
I'm glad someone mentioned Rubicon ...
I'm glad someone mentioned Rubicon before I could. Can't believe they didn't make the list.
yes-shit...
yes-shit
I AGree...
I AGree
This list is brilliant. And of course, ...
This list is brilliant. And of course, shit songs are a sign of a healthy music industry - there's room for everyone!
// 4) Double J and Twice the T - Def To Be Green
This was a water conservation song. It chorus is burned in my memory.
// 7) Blackjack - Kurt Cobain
The most important thing about this song, the thing that should possibly even bump up this song's placing: Blackjack rhyme "Cobain" and "pain".
As for new additions, the trick is not to just spew out "[any song] by [band I don't like]", but rather to think about terrible songs by otherwise decent bands.
For example, I think Nesian Mystik are a cool group who have written some good songs, but their first single "Nesian Style" was terrible. Simple (in a bad way) guitar and simpler lyrics. It's almost like a parody of a Nesian Mystik song. Oooh, Nesians, ooh, Nesians. Urgh.
I should also note that the Blackjack ...
I should also note that the Blackjack song is actually called "Don't have a gun".
Written by Scott Davies. From the Album ...
Written by Scott Davies. From the Album "Kicasso d'Muse"
Stop, Drop And Roll by Deceptikons is ...
Stop, Drop And Roll by Deceptikons is incredibly bad.
Its about time someone realised that ...
Its about time someone realised that (hearing it blasting out of cars etc over and over again doesn't help either)
... and Not Many by Scribe is ...
... and Not Many by Scribe is unforgivable.
there's a remix of stop drop n' roll ...
there's a remix of stop drop n' roll thats been playing on RadioActive thats even worse than the original. .
i thought SD&R was nice as a little outro at the end of that mareko(here to stay) song, but i dunno about it being worthy of an entire single to itself
I hated Stop Drop & Roll ar the first ...
I hated Stop Drop & Roll ar the first hint of it, and then it fucking took over, errrr!
It's such a stupid lyric. They should write their next track around "Only a fool breaks the 2 second rule", which I think would be a massive hit in the same vain!
Have Fun in the Water But Do What You ...
Have Fun in the Water But Do What You Oughta perhaps?
Come on Guys, Get Fire Wise?
Mark, The Car's On Fire! ?
It's the Same Day David
Slip Slop Slap
Don't drink and fry....
Don't drink and fry.