Creatine and sporting supplements

Does creatine and other supplments work? and/or work well?

Anyone have any experience with this stuff?

If you do, do you recommend any particular brand ?

Forums: The Bar,

I have a couple of semi-pro (France) rugby player friends who used creatine while they were playing and swore by it. They definitely bulked up quickly when they started using it regularly.

The EAS stuff works too, if you stick to the eating/exercise regime. Tastes like crap tho.

apparently the Warriors use the EAS stuff...Not sure how if thats a good thing given their current form. haha

i don't know what you're planning on using it for, but apparently it works, for muscle building and anaerobic (high intensity, short) performance .. . so if your looking at running a marathon, it might pay to use something else. . .also taking it with simple carbs helps it to absorb better. . .

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/creatine ]

Im looking to gain weight and muscle for Rugby. I am currently about 90kilos and looking to get up to 95kilos +

Dan I started weightlifting while at school, ( quite sometime ago now .. ) I was about 15 I think and my P.E teacher was a scottish bloke called Bill Sharp, who aparently used to know a bloke called Geoff Capes, it was bill who got me started, he would let me off P.E and I'd go to the weight room .. which was a disused garage we'd convereted at the school ... and I'd push weights there, and he ran a class in the evening once a week too, I did that for about three years about four / five times aweek till I left school, that was my start, after that I did two physical jobs but didn't do the weights, till I joined the Navy at 20 when I got back into them .. I've been in London now for about 16.5 years now and although I've been to the gym a few times I've not really done anything for some time .. the point to all this ramble is .. at no time in my life have I used or needed to use steroids or any other " Power muscle " building supplement type thing, yes I've put on weight after stopping the weightlifting, I'm about 25/26 stone but I think that's more to do with the fact that I stopped working out, but didn't stop the eating side of things, I still have abit of tone and I put that down to the fact I didn't use any of the above muscle enhancing stuff .. The way to bulk up is easy in my books .. eat plenty, plenty of anything, heavy weights low reps .. one of the times I went back to the gym here I was doing 40kgs on the machines .. I was doing 5 reps three times that worked out at 40kgs x 5 = 200kgs x 3 = 600kgs I did that with about 8 of the machines .. that's about 4800kgs .. then I did the free weights leg press 350kgs x 5 x 3 bench press 80kgs x 5 x 3 .. arm curls 40kgs again x 5 x 3 plus a few other bits and bobs .. all up in about an hour and a half I'd lifted about 11800 odd kgs .. it may come across as a brag .. but it isn't, it's how I built up and got big .. hard work and alittle focus ... supplements can be avoided by just eating healthy and heaps and working out in the right way ... simple equation .. eat, heavy weights low reps, puts on weight, if that's what your after that's the way forward .. sorry about the babble Dan ...

//sorry about the babble Dan ...

haha Nah man that was very interesing. Might have to give it a go.

Eating isn't a problem hahahah, stupid metabolism just chews through the food I eat anyways. I have always had trouble putting on weight ( which believe it or not is actually an annoying thing ) Most people try to keep weight off and here I am trying to put it on haha, and being only around 8 or 9 % body fat theres not much I have to turn to muscle.

But yeah I have taken that on board...Let the eating begin.

//I have always had trouble putting on weight

Enjoy it while you still can. That won't be such a problem in another 5 years...

^^^ Yeah so I keep getting told. I am a pretty active person though so I burn any fat off pretty fast.

If you do it Dan, just pick a weight your comfy with, start off with say 15 / 20 kgs most people can handle that weight, just heavy enough to know about, do the exercises slowly as in don't go one, two, three, four, five .. go onnee, twwooo, threee .. etc and really make your muscles feel it, it's as much about the control of the weight as it is about the weight of the weight .. if that makes any sence .. :-) !! if your doing bench press, make sure the weight hit's your chest and you push up from there and not just bend your elbows abit thinking it's accomplishing the same thing ... well Dan I'll stop my preaching .. I'm not the biggest bloke in the world, but the above worked for me, and even today at 40 I still have alittle tone left even though I've haven't touched a weight in a good few years ... good luck with the weight gain mate ..

It aint preaching at least you know what you are talking about haha.

It is good advice.Cheers man.

One last thing in that case mate .. :-) if your going to do it, make sure you balance it out, as in work out the lower body as much as the upper, do leg press and squats and other assorted leg and thigh exercises, also when doing curls etc try standing, stand ridged with legs / back straight, you'll have to balance the curls with your body, which means your legs and back take some of the strain you sould feel your bum and hamstrings pulling to counter balance .. last word mate, your solo, let me know how you get on, I'd be interested in how you do ...

Will do mate. Thanks for the advice once again.

How's the weight gain going mate ? You still at the gym ?

Man, this shit always dodges me out a little. It really does fly too close to doping for me - though I don't know enough about it to judge.

1) You know how body builders get really fat after they retire? Is this just because they don't use their muscles or due to the abandonment of supplements?

2) If you took creatine and didn't work out, would you get fat?

3) Are there side effects (like steroids which shrink your peepee)?

4) Why isn't this banned? What's the difference between this and putting more blood into your body like the Tour de France riders (disregarding the health dangers of blood-adding)?

//I don't know enough about it to judge.

Heather's 1/2 hour surf-research bubble (grain of salt please, this is the internet): creatine already occurs naturally in the muscles and in some foods, so taking creatine is tantamount to taking a vitamin supplement. It's produced synthetically, but only because extraction from red meat is too expensive. You won't gain weight: if you don't use it then your muscles will store as much as they are able, and your body will just flush out the rest. A few people experience diaorrhea or a tummy ache, but usually because they're taking more than the recommended dose. So far that's the worst of the side-effects. Researchers are still watching out for long-term side-effects; particularly any bad effects on the heart, but so far none have been forthcoming.

//1) You know how body builders get really fat after they retire? Is this just because they don't use their muscles or due to the abandonment of supplements?

Anyone who stops lifting weights will experience muscle loss, it is actually amazing how fast you lose it, BUT when you start again you regain the "lost" muscle fairly quickly, I lost 15kgs when I was sick, 10 of which was put on from weights and just in the last 3 months I have put most of it back on. They say that within 6 weeks of stopping weights etc you will lose somethig crazy like 40% of your muscle mass almost straight away.

2) If you took creatine and didn't work out, would you get fat?

Yeah most likely. If you eat to much bread and don't do anything physical you get fat too.

3) Are there side effects (like steroids which shrink your peepee)?

It's creatine not steroids.

4) Why isn't this banned? What's the difference between this and putting more blood into your body like the Tour de France riders (disregarding the health dangers of blood-adding)?

It isn't an illegel drug. It is natural supplement. Blood doping is a different thing altogether that is cheating as fas as I can see taking creatine is not.

I am really keen to know if its worked for anyone and what the best brands are. I am thinking of trying out the EAS stuff but can't be assed wasting my money if it is all just hype.

//If you eat to much bread and don't do anything physical you get fat too.

There's a difference between not working out and not doing anything physical. I think what I was meaning, if you do a lot of aerobic exercise but not much anaerobic, do you bulk up generally or is it not used?

//It's creatine not steroids

Yeah, I know. I was using steroids as an example of something that has negative side effects.

//Blood doping is a different thing altogether that is cheating as fas as I can see taking creatine is not.

I don't think we're talking about the same thing. Some athletes remove normal blood a few weeks before a race, and put it back in just before the event, boosting their oxygen capacities. This is illegal... but why. if not creatine?

//There's a difference between not working out and not doing anything physical. I think what I was meaning, if you do a lot of aerobic exercise but not much anaerobic, do you bulk up generally or is it not used?

Yeah true, I am not sure, I guess it would either just store or just waste away. It is meant to work with both aerobic and anaerobic work too boost performance and all that.

//I don't think we're talking about the same thing. Some athletes remove normal blood a few weeks before a race, and put it back in just before the event, boosting their oxygen capacities. This is illegal... but why. if not creatine?

Yes and the removel of the blood and adding it back is called Blood Doping. It is just like using a Whey protein or other spoting supplements it. You arent removing anything to give you an advantage over your opponent and I guess if you don't work out nothing will happen and you won't benefit from taking it.

It doesn't unnaturally enhance your performance or body, ( So they say ) it allows you to do extra reps and muscles to recover faster between sets and stuff at the gym so you still have to do the hard work for it to work or for you to have any benefit. Blood Doping is cheating by adding more red blood cells the your body to carry the oxygen like you said, this artificially enhances your performance while using a natural substance creatine doesn't do this...

I guess that answers your " Does it do anything if you don't work out?" question.

But I have spoken to alot of people who have said it doesn't work anyways so I duno, might have to try it for myself.

//But I have spoken to alot of people who have said it doesn't work anyways so I duno, might have to try it for myself.

Probably it's a bit difficult to work out whether there's a marked difference; from what I gather it sort of has a cumulative effect, so while you might possibly notice you can benchpress more for longer for a week or two after you start taking it, you wouldn't notice so much in the longer term; much like any kind of diet & exercise. I imagine if you started taking it when you're already well built, or with a good healthy bulking-up-style diet it'd probably have less of an impact as well.

//blood doping

Thing about creatine is that you're already consuming it in normal foods; only to get the kind of amounts you get from supplementing, you'd have to eat about 5kg of steak a day. The websites I looked at recommended against that because it's bad for your cholestrol levels. :-S

I can speak on Creatine from personal experience.

I've just come off of my second round of Creatine supplementation. Following what I've read in research journals and online each round should be confined to about 6 weeks - constant use isn't recommended as long term in may damage your kidneys. Not to freak you or anything though... you just have to take precautions.

Creatine enhances both anaebolic and aerobic performance. Although it is mainly used for bulking up it also enhances muscle stamina, so as well as being able to lift more for longer you can also power along on the cardio machines or go hard

http://ferrouswheel.blogspot.com ]

gah, sorry. I clicked add by mistake...

as I was saying. You can perform at your peak in whatever sport is your choice.

The general regime is a power dose for about a week to increase the residual creatine levels in your body, and during this time you should slowly begin to notice the effects. Creatine does bulk you up and cause weight gain, it also causes your muscles to swell from weight gain which I found a bit disconcerting because I prefer strong lean muscle to huge swelling muscle. This effect continues and the rate at which you can increase your weight loads increases... or if you had already plateaued than it gives you an extra hill to conquer. If I remember correctly this swelling is due to water retention - although I'm really making this sound much worse than it is.

I suspect that doing no exercise at the same time will cause you to gain weight and maybe look bigger for a while. However that brings me to what happens when you come off of it...

When you come off your bulk gradual decreases to reveal the same muscles you had before - they are slightly larger and you can lift more than you could before taking creatine, I also think they are leaner. The second time I took it the increase wasn't as great tho.

In between Creatine regimes make sure you have at least 4 weeks break to be on the safe side.
(Note: while taking creatine I did at least 3 intense 1.5 hour gym sessions per week and 2 martial arts classes which are pretty intense too... not sure what the minimum amount of exercise you'd need to do is to get good results).

I also recommend Lecithin which is a supplement for mobilising fat, has the added benefit of providing more energy to your brain too.

So the kidney load would mean you probably shouldn't drink too much while on creatine?

Ha ha. I am like the last person who would ever take creatine.

Latest Classified Ads