WHY IS IT WELINGTIN HAVE BEST ROCK BANDS IN NZ?

WHY IS IT THAT THE CAPITIL CITI OF WELINGTIN NZ HAVE THE BEST ROKC BANDS AND LIVE ONES?

BART BODEGA

Forums: NZ Music,

It is because TBM's (Tunnel Boring Machines) were originally designed for aerial combat, not picking sunflower seeds from orphaned bulldoser cavities. It could also be because Bill Clinton appeared with electro-magnetic bunny rabbit chewing on frequent over the tooth brush. You deside...

You have asked a very pertinent question BART BODEGA. Me of the long list would like to know why Wellington has the best rock bands in New Zealand?

Is it because we have a diverse music scene that accepts many genres or is it because there are some very good organisers that put really good shows together? Maybe audiences are receptive to a wider range of styles and attend gigs with a more open mind?

ok, two things wrong with that...

Firstly the fact that you just swallowed automatically the line that wellington has "better" rock bands than any other place in NZ. Probably I'm just being precious, but it's more to do with the point dusty made in another thread that the categorisation of music by city doesn't really cut it any more.

Secondly, none of your suggestions have anything to do with how "good" a band is. Of course, this is in keeping with your general approach to music which seems to have a whole lot more to do with marketability than talent, so I guess that's not unexpected.

I didn't automatically swallow anything!

As you know Heather I do very thorough research and simply found a strong affinity with BARTs question. I would like to know why it is that Wellington has the best rock bands in New Zealand.

// I would like to know why it is that Wellington has the best rock bands in New Zealand.

how often do you go and see bands in other cities?

As regularly as I see bands in Wellington!

Hey Bart,

Can you please not write in ALLCAPS for your posts. Many thanks.

I don't think that BART knows how to do that!!!

This Bart character is based on BRIAN who is an internet forum legend.

He posts in all caps and speaks like a handi-capped kid. He usually spouts off about his brother and going to the Rock n Roll McDonalds etc.

I don't think this person has captured his persona very well though. The incarnations I've seen have been very, very funny.

I am certain that BART is an individual - he is definitely his own person. When he rang me at MUNT he didn't sound like a handi-capped kid but he certainly does seem a little immature.

Intetresting hearing about a BRIAN character.

I thought BART was having a go at me wanting to have my pop band play at McDonalds restaurants!!!!

can someone please point me to these "best rock bands" that are wellingtons? its been too long since i went to see a wellington band. and the ones opening for unwellington bands have been very dissapointing. thanks.

Shihad! Head Like a Hole! Weta! Short! Letterbox Lambs! Sheesh, try to stay current!

you know that half those bands havent played in years right... arg, i feel like im wading into some cunning trap ..

i want good bands though.

lady luck, quality grass

that's some eloquent phrasing there, samflux

http://thebigcity.co.nz ]

//that's some eloquent phrasing there, samflux

im gonna choose to take that as a compliment - being friday and all

Alabaster Theatre rock well. I'll chuck you an MP3 when it's finished mixing

why is it that eketahuna has the thirteenth best rock bands in nz?

dumb luck, quality grass

thanks speedy

I don't especially like any rock bands from wellington. Shihad are the best of the bunch (id forgotten they were from welly though), but that isn't saying much. Having said that, wellington is special for its awesome dub bands. Personally i think nz dub kicks nz rock in the nuts really hard. Just my opinion though.

It is good that we are supposed to be allowed to have an opinion isn't it!

All cities have there times of great bands...and the era of wellington 'rock' bands was definately the 90's. Dunners had the 'indy' bands of the eighties... Chch had the rock'n'roll swagger of the early sixties. AK had the late 70s punk explosion etc etc. I don't really go to many gigs these days as I'm becoming a lazy old man but I have not seen a 'rock' band from wellington in ages that i thought was awesome (although I havn't seen the Users or Lady Luck, both of whom are supposed to be the shit). I sort of think auckland has a better scene at the moment...despite it fashionista leanings.

Just my humble opion though, maybe Welllington is awesome at the moment and I just can't see the wood(rock) for the trees(bands)

// I don't really go to many gigs these days as I'm becoming a lazy old man...

the Island Bay syndrome...

I'm not sure what rock is. Are the Chandeliers rock? Are Connans and the Mockasins rock? Are So So Modern rock? The Users? etc...etc...fuck knows... there are so many great wellington bands around right now, but i wouldn't call any of them rock.

the chandeliers rock....is that close enough. Yeah Blinkydink there is heaps of good music in wellingotn right now, but no more than there is in Auckland...or Chicago (actually there is probably morew good music coming out of chicago but hey)

I don't knoe maybe wegtn has heaps better bands than auckland but i really hate those sort of claims coz it turns music in to sport which is so off track. Like when poeple say "hey you guys blew thae main act off the stage"...ergh yek i hat that line

fuck, i certainly don't think we need to get into better bands per capita or ranking bands in different cities..thats what councils do... congrats on recieving a B ranking from the council anway :)

to be honest though, Dunedin rules and always has, i saw a wonderful new band there the otherday called "zan batman circus", hmm..not sure about that name, but great all the same. Couldn't get past round 1 of the dunedin RQ, yet showed more song writing skills then i seen in eons. Some sort of choice blend of The Cure, Wire, The yeah yeah yeahs and HDU. I love it when my faith in the yoof is restored.

to- hey you guys blew thae main act off the stage- ive always found that a- ¿what did you fuckin expect cunt?- & a quick loogie in the face is most expedient

regions in nz don't compete. stop spreading that myth.

...

// regions in nz don't compete.

no region can compete with the southern lakes and milford sound anyway. no chance.

whats this city council list?

sorry bro...it was in that other terrible "wellington scene" forum.

http://www.positivelywellingtonbusiness.co.nz/assets/WGTN_MUSIC_REPORT_w...

a guide to bands in wellington and their profiles within the industry. with a handy A to F ranking, just incase you needed to compare the profile of Brooke Fraser to The Accelerants. I don't know how we got by without it.

external link ]

Bunnies On Ponies are an E... which is pretty good based on our three gigs. What a funny report! It said Dave Long was the only local producer of note, and yes he is great but if Lee Prebble isn't of note (producing three diferent platinum albums in the last four years, two tui nominations as producer/engineer, producing albums that have won many many bnet awards and been nominated for many tuis etc etc, developing his own studio, mixing new Dobyn album) then i do not know what is.

"to be honest though, Dunedin rules and always has, i saw a wonderful new band there the otherday called "zan batman circus", hmm..not sure about that name, but great all the same."

You are right with the name Blink. a bit more info on them on dunedinmusic.com. On my list of bands to see. Dunedin's scene is exploding at the moment, but unfortunately few venture beyond the city boundaries and most are criminally under-appreciated in their home town. Folks seem happy to turn out for (some) bands from other places and ignore the local talent. Need more A Low Hum tours to get numbers through the doors...

Blink, is that Wellington Music Report for real?
It just seems odd that they'd want to rank bands like that. And it says it was written by a Rocky Douche.

// Blink, is that Wellington Music Report for real?

i wish i had the time to create such an elaborate ruse.

Nah, it would be boring writing all of that stuff....................

ALL OF THE GOOD HOT GOOD THIKN BANDS OF THE CAPITIL CITI OF WELINGTIN LIKE THE CHECS THEY ARE A TOP HOT GOOD ROCK BAND IN THIS FIME CITI

MAN U SUK HARD BRAT BRODEGRA.. WHI IS IT THAT YOU ARE ALWAYS MAKING OF THESE GHASTLY POSTS....? IS IT BECAUSE THE CAPITAL CITY OF WELLINGTON YADDA YADDA SCHMENKIDDY SMAH....

VETO are the greatest.

http://www.veto.co.nz ]

I like your band names.

i dont like it
the drumming is not good enough

Ronald; could atleast give them constructive criticism mate. example; what about the drumming isnt good enough? Does the timing need to be tightened up. its all very well saying 'its not good enough' but give them some pointers as to why so they can actually work on it. Its the difference between being 'an opinionated git' and 'an honest critic'.

I like the band names!

leave bart alone you dickheads. i hate people that put people down. theres also heaps of wankers in trademe too. they just cant go away and leave some people alone.

bart is obviously a little diff. i reckin bart has some probs in the head but he seems frendly and he hasnt done any harm. just leave him alone. theres people in trade me too that just put people down. i hate it.

last time i came here people told me not to swear soo much so maybe bart will stop using capitals like i am not swearing so much. i just really want to tell the cool police to f off but i wont cause i hate it when people are mean like in trade me.

Its just the capitals thing man....

Bart - I do not think that you are dumb!

At the moment I can't wait to hear your MUNT fm broadcast on Tuesday. Your wise words will not fall upon deaf ears. More people will be tuning in to 88.5fm this week or listening to the online stream from 11.00am.

Go BART BODEGA patron of Wellington arts!!!!!!!

'Why Wellington is at the top?' Last week I thought I heard you mention something about 'The importance of keeping a diary...........?' I daresay we will get the low down on Tuesday.

http://www.muntfm.co.nz ]

Bahaha! Bart's your troll, isn't he Tane! Are you disappointed noone's yet pointed out the checks are from auckland?

PS, dynamix, if you write one more post with *any* further permutations of the words "I", "hate", "the", "cool", "police" and "trademe", I'm afraid I'm going to have to bitchslap you.